Newark Drunk Driving Accident Lawyers
Knowing that another driver chose to get behind the wheel while impaired can make an already painful experience even harder to accept. You may be facing serious injuries, time away from work, and a long recovery, all because of someone else’s reckless decision.
While the driver may face criminal charges, a DWI prosecution does not automatically provide compensation for your injuries. You have the right to pursue a separate civil claim without waiting for the criminal case to end.
At Goldstein & Goldstein, LLP, our Newark drunk driving accident lawyers help injured people pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, and other losses.
We investigate the crash, gather evidence from the criminal investigation, and handle your injury claim while you focus on recovering.
You should not have to wait for the criminal case to move forward before seeking help. Contact our firm for a free consultation. You pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you.
What Does Goldstein & Goldstein, LLP Bring to a Drunk Driving Case?
Since 1997, Goldstein & Goldstein, LLP has represented injured people throughout Newark and Essex County. Our family-owned firm combines decades of legal experience with personal attention to every case.
- Four attorneys with more than 50 years of combined experience.
- One New Jersey Supreme Court Certified Civil Trial Attorney, partner Michael J. Goldstein, ready to try a case when an insurer will not be fair.
- 316 Google reviews with a 4.7-star average.
- Three languages at intake, English, Spanish, and Haitian Creole, with help available 24/7.
- Zero fees unless we recover money for you, under our No Recovery, No Fee arrangement.
We also connect clients with an established network of treating doctors, and drunk driving claims are one part of the broader personal injury work our family does for Newark residents.
How Does the Criminal Case Compare to Your Injury Claim?
Many people assume the criminal case will cover their losses, or that they must wait for it to finish. Neither is true, and waiting can cost you. The two cases differ in almost every way, from who controls them to what they can achieve.
| Question | The DWI or criminal case | Your civil injury claim |
|---|---|---|
| Who brings it | The State, through the prosecutor or municipal court | You, through your own lawyer |
| Its purpose | Penalties such as fines, license suspension, or jail | Compensation for your injuries and losses |
| Standard of proof | Beyond a reasonable doubt | More likely than not |
| Your role | Victim and possible witness | The party bringing the claim |
| Who pays | The driver, through penalties | Usually the driver’s insurer, up to policy limits |
| Timing | Set by the criminal court’s calendar | Generally must be filed within two years of the crash |
Because a civil case needs less proof, your injury claim can succeed even if the driver is acquitted, the charges are reduced, or the criminal case is still open.
How Can Evidence From the DWI Case Help Your Claim?
The criminal investigation often turns up evidence that helps the civil case. How each piece can be used depends on the record and the rules of evidence.
Breath and Blood Test Results
Breath and blood test results record how impaired the driver was. We request them from the investigating agency once your claim is underway, and when the test was taken compared to the crash can matter.
Police Observations and Body Camera Footage
Officers usually document slurred speech, the smell of alcohol, unsteady movements, and field sobriety tests. Body camera and dashcam footage of the stop can be powerful proof of the driver’s condition. Accounts from other drivers and bystanders back up what officers saw.
Convictions, Pleas, and Refusals
A DWI conviction, a plea, or a refusal charge can each affect the civil case differently. We review the municipal or criminal court record to see what was decided, how it can be used, and whether the court entered any orders.
Where the Driver Was Drinking
Receipts, bar tabs, and statements about where the driver spent the evening help reconstruct how much was consumed and who served it. That matters if a bar or host may share the blame.
How Do Impaired Driving Crashes Typically Happen Around Newark?
Drunk driving accidents can happen in several ways, from wrong-way highway collisions to late-night crashes near Newark’s entertainment districts. How the accident happened can help identify the evidence needed to establish liability.
Wrong-Way Highway Crashes
An impaired driver who takes an exit ramp by mistake can end up driving against traffic on the Turnpike, I-78, or Route 21. These head-on collisions can cause devastating injuries to everyone involved.
Ramp design, signs, and where the driver had been earlier that night may all become part of the investigation.
Late-Night Crashes Near Downtown Venues
Concerts, games, and nightlife draw big crowds downtown and in the Ironbound, and some people drive home after drinking. Receipts, venue records, and video help establish where a driver had been and how much was served.
Repeat Offenders
Some impaired drivers have prior DWI convictions or suspended licenses. That history can matter to the criminal case, to punitive damages, and to whether anyone who lent the driver a car knew the risk.
Does the Verbal Threshold Still Apply When the Driver Was Drunk?
In most cases, yes. Your own auto policy may carry the limitation on lawsuit option. If it does, the threshold generally still governs your claim for pain and other non-economic losses, even when the at-fault driver was drunk.
Bills that would have created an exception for drunk driving crashes, such as A2736, were introduced but never passed. The state’s auto insurance buyer’s guide explains how the lawsuit option works. The threshold does not limit economic losses like unpaid medical bills and lost wages.
What Losses Does a Drunk Driving Claim Need to Account For?
Impaired driving crashes often happen at high speed or head-on, so injuries tend to be serious and recovery long. A claim may need to cover surgeries, rehabilitation, time off work, reduced earning ability, and the physical pain and limits the injury causes.
A drunk driving accident claim may involve compensatory damages for your injuries and, in some cases, punitive damages for particularly reckless conduct. Each requires different evidence, including documentation of your losses and proof of the driver’s actions.
When Are Punitive Damages Available Against a Drunk Driver?
Punitive damages punish especially reckless conduct, and drunk driving can qualify. New Jersey’s Punitive Damages Act requires clear and convincing proof of actual malice or wanton and willful disregard for others’ safety, and the model jury charge explains how juries weigh that standard.
The Cap and Its Drunk Driving Exception
New Jersey generally caps punitive damages at five times compensatory damages or $350,000, whichever is greater. However, certain criminal convictions can remove that cap under N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.14(c).
Whether the exception applies depends on the specific offense and circumstances of the case.
Insurance and Punitive Awards
Whether an auto policy covers punitive damages depends on the policy and the circumstances. When it does not, collecting a punitive award may depend on the driver’s personal assets. That is part of deciding whether to pursue punitive damages at all.
What Is Your Role in the Criminal Case?
As a crash victim, you may hear from the prosecutor’s office or a victim-witness advocate. You can generally choose to stay informed about the case, and you may be asked to testify. You do not have to go through it unprepared.
Restitution
A criminal court may order the driver to pay restitution for certain out-of-pocket losses. Restitution is usually narrow and does not replace a civil claim for the full range of damages, like pain and lasting limits.
Statements to Prosecutors
What you tell investigators and prosecutors becomes part of the criminal record and may be reviewed later in the civil case. Talk with your injury lawyer before giving detailed statements so the two cases stay consistent. We can help you prepare for those conversations.
Victim Impact Statements
If the driver is convicted, you may be able to describe how the crash affected you before sentencing. That statement is part of the criminal process and separate from proving damages in your civil claim.
What if the Drunk Driver Fled or Had No Insurance?
Impaired drivers sometimes leave the scene, and some have no insurance or only minimum limits. Uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage on your own or a household policy may step in. Our Newark hit and run page covers cases where the driver left.
Passengers Who Rode With an Impaired Driver
Passengers hurt while riding with an impaired driver can generally bring claims against that driver’s insurer. An insurer may argue that a passenger who knew the driver was visibly drunk shares some blame. That argument turns on what the passenger actually knew.
When a Drunk Driving Crash Is Fatal
Families who lose someone in an impaired driving crash may bring wrongful death and survival claims, generally within two years of the death. The criminal case may be a vehicular homicide prosecution, and the civil claim moves forward separately on its own timeline.
FAQs About Drunk Driving Accidents in Newark
Do I need the drunk driver to be convicted to win my claim?
A New Jersey injury claim does not require a criminal conviction, because a civil case uses a lower standard of proof. A conviction still helps as evidence, and it can decide whether the punitive damages cap applies.
Can I recover if the driver’s blood alcohol was under 0.08?
A New Jersey driver whose blood alcohol was below 0.08 may still have been impaired enough to drive carelessly, and drugs or a mix of substances can impair driving at any level. Commercial drivers are held to a lower 0.04 limit.
Will I have to testify in the criminal case?
Crash victims in New Jersey are sometimes subpoenaed to testify in the criminal or municipal case, especially if the driver fights the charges. Many cases resolve without a trial, so testimony is not always needed, but it pays to be prepared.
How long does the criminal case usually take?
A New Jersey DWI or criminal case can take months, and longer when serious injury charges are involved. Your civil claim does not need to wait, and preserving evidence and filing on time should not depend on the criminal calendar.
What if the drunk driver was under 21?
A New Jersey driver under 21 faces stricter alcohol rules, and an underage driver’s family auto policy often provides the coverage for an injury claim. Anyone who supplied alcohol to the underage driver may also face scrutiny.
Pursue Your Newark Drunk Driving Injury Claim Without Waiting on the Criminal Case

Richard Goldstein, Newark Drunk Driving Accident Lawyer
You do not have to wait for the drunk driver’s criminal case to end before seeking compensation for your injuries. You can participate in the criminal proceedings as a victim while pursuing a separate civil claim for your losses.
Because the two cases follow different timelines, it is important to protect your right to compensation before the civil filing deadline expires.
Partner Michael J. Goldstein is a New Jersey Supreme Court Certified Civil Trial Attorney. Contact Goldstein & Goldstein, LLP, for a free consultation to discuss your injuries and legal options.
We can review the circumstances of your accident, explain your options, and begin investigating the evidence that may support your claim.
Results depend on the specific facts of each case, and past outcomes do not predict future results.